Friday, 22 April 2016

Grade 9 Applied Innovative Lesson

                           
I think that this was a great way to find, share, and select lessons that can be used to make learning topics more entertaining, and interactive for all different types of learners. I loved the opportunity to focus on grade 9 applied as it was very hands on! I also liked the exposure to high school grades as Brock primarily focuses on the junior / intermediate grades 4-8!



  Innovative Social Studies Lesson Review

Alexandra Ramos

Section: Thursday 5-8pm
8P10
Grade 9 Applied

Financial Literacy  
Topic: Consumerism
Overall Expectation:
E1.  Sustainable Communities: identify factors that affect the sustainability of communities, and describe strategies for improving their sustainability (FOCUS ON: Interrelationships; Geographic Perspective)
E3.  Patterns of Land Use: describe patterns of land use in their local community (FOCUS ON: Spatial Signi cance; Patterns and Trends)

Specific Expectations:

Related Concept of Social Studies, Historical or Geographic Thinking



E1.1 use a variety of measurements (e.g., ecological footprint, carbon footprint, water footprint) to compare the impact on the natural environment of people in Canada and people in other countries
E1.2 identify various ways in which communities in Canada dispose of their waste material
(e.g., land lling, composting, incineration, primary and secondary sewage treatment), and describe potential environmental impacts of these methods
E1.3 describe ways in which communities can improve their environmental sustainability
E1.4 identify actions that individuals can take to live more sustainably, and explain the bene ts for their local community
E3.3 identify spatial connections between human systems and services in their community and the broader regional, national, and/or global networks to which they belong (e.g., food distribution, communications, transportation, and energy networks)
Using spatial skills: Students can create maps to illustrate connections between various communities and other regions and networks, such as farming regions and transportation and energy networks.
Big Ideas:
How will environmental issues impact the future of Canada and the world?
Evaluate various ways of ensuring resource sustainability in Canada.


How can individual actions can make a community more sustainable.  
Framing Question to Foster Inquiry
What makes a community sustainable?
What can happen is a community is not sustainable?

Why is it important that we think about the food growing capacity of the earth?


What are the major differences when you compare Canada to International consumerism?
How can you change your way of living to reduce your consumption of resources?
What roles do various industries play in your community?
Which of Canada’s natural resources do you think has the most important uses?


Knowledge & Skills Categories Addressed


I can explain some of the environmental and financial impacts of purchasing local foods.

I can explain the ways in which consumer awareness can affect food purchasing decisions.

I can identify some of the steps in food production.

I can make accurate comparisons of the costs of store bought foods and foods prepared at home.
Assessment Strategies
Assessment for learning: Issues regarding our food supply can be assessed from their answers in the whole- group discussion.
Assessment for learning: students understand the production processes, their benefits and can be assessed in the Apples to Applesauce activity.  
Assessment as learning: consult with small groups to support them as they complete their meal analysis.

DI: Encourage students to think of alternative meals that would be reflective of diverse cultures
Materials & Resources
Apple

Cutting board and knife
Pictures (or cards with words on them)
apples and applesauce

Quiz & Trade” Cue Cards
Meal Analysis Chart, Meal Cards

Copies of articles about buying local food such as: http://thelocavore.ca/
http://www.niagararegion.ca/government/initiatives/lfap/why-buy-local.aspx http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/ontario/ontario-gives-homegrown-food-a-boost/article2124555/






Lesson Description


Minds On: The Earth as An Apple
Introduce the concepts of food production and sustainability issues by doing a simulation activity with the earth being represented as an apple.

Procedure:
- Cut the apple into four quarters and set aside three of the quarters.
- These represent the seas and oceans of the world.
- The fourth quarter represents the total land area of the earth.
- Slice this land quarter in half, giving two 1/8th world pieces, representing pieces of the earth.
- Set aside one of the pieces to represent land that people cannot live on, like polar areas, deserts, swamps, very high or rocky mountainous areas.
- The other 1/8th piece represents land where people live, but cannot necessarily grow the foods needed for life.
- Now slice this 1/8th piece into four sections, giving four 1/32nd pieces.
-  Set aside three of these pieces to represent areas that are too rocky, too wet, too cold, too steep, or with soil too poor to produce food.
- They also include the areas of land that could produce food but are buried under cities, highways, suburban developments, shopping centers and other structures people have built.
- This leaves a 1/32nd slice of the earth. Carefully peel this slice.
- This tiny bit of peeling represents the surface of the earth in which food can grow and on which all human life depends.

Consolidate:  
What can you conclude about our food growing capacity?
What can you conclude about land use, agriculture and geography?


Activity:
Whole Class ➔ Apples to Applesauce
Create an imaginary line in the classroom.
Place a sign with the word “Apple” at one end of the line and a sign with the words “Apple Sauce” at the other end of the line. (Images of an apple and apple sauce can also be used.)
Give students one minute to think of all of the steps that are involved with getting the apple hanging from a tree to a jar of applesauce in a grocery store!
Invite a student to identify a step involved in getting apples to applesauce. The students take a place on the line to represent when in the production process their identified step takes place. Invite other students to identify other steps in the process and to take their place on the line relative to the other students who are already on the line.

As a class or in pairs, students respond to the questions:
What are the benefits or drawbacks of eating processed apple sauce rather than a whole apple?
Based on this exercise that we’ve just completed, what are the things to think about with eating processed apple sauce?
(Possible responses could include: Even for a relatively unprocessed food, there are a lot of steps involved in getting applesauce to the store shelf. We need to be aware of the resources that are used to process our food.)


Small Group  
Placemat Activity: Consumer Awareness
In small groups, students brainstorm responses to a reflective question about current food issues and consumer responsibility. Questions include topics such as shopping patterns, use of antibiotics in meat, organic farming, and the impact of buying locally, the availability of local foods in different communities. In their groups, they share and discuss individual ideas.


As a class, students share ideas and discuss factors that influence decisions to shop in different ways (e.g., time, cost, convenience/availability).


Guiding Questions:
  • How much does price influence where you and your family shop?
  • Do you think supporting local producers or having low cost options is more important?
  • Is it possible to find a balance between these two things?
  • When you are grocery shopping with your family do you look for the symbol or
    a sign that indicates Ontario grown produce or products? Why or why not?
  • Is convenience or quality more important to you and your family when making
  • shopping decisions? Why or why not?
  • Do you and your family consider factors such as supporting local businesses
    and food production processes and ethical consumption when making buying decisions?  


Individual/ Whole Class ➔ Article Reading


“Quiz, Quiz, Trade” Activity Students select an article about local foods to read.
After students have read the articles, each student receives a card with a question and sample responses or discussion points for the question, related to the articles. Students mingle throughout the classroom, quizzing each other. After sharing their responses, they high ve their partner then trade cards and move on to a new partner to discuss another question. Students share information with their partner if their partner is not sure of the answer.


Small Groups ➔ Meal Analysis In small groups, students analyses the cost, appearance, and environmental impact of a store-bought pre-packaged meal. Each group receives a specific meal to analyse. Remind students that when considering the cost of the meal, they should think about factors such as the yield – how much does the meal cost per serving? Students complete the rst half of the Meal Analysis Chart in class. The second half of the Meal Analysis Chart is completed on a eld trip to a farmers’ market. If a eld trip is not possible, students can complete their Meal Analysis Chart on their own time in their groups. As an extension activity, students could also prepare their home made meals in class with products purchased as a class at the farmers’ market.


Concepts
Addressed
What Concepts of Disciplinary Thinking are addressed in this lesson?
C1. Managing Resources: assess the in uence of personal choices and community actions on the use of natural resources in Canada (FOCUS ON: Interrelationships; Geographic Perspective)
C2. Canadian Industries: describe the economic, environmental, social, and political signi cance of selected aspects of Canada’s resources and industries (FOCUS ON: Patterns and Trends; Geographic Perspective)
C3. The Use of Natural Resources: describe the distribution and use of selected natural resources in Canada (FOCUS ON: Spatial Signi cance; Interrelationships)

E1. Sustainable Communities: identify factors that affect the sustainability of communities, and describe strategies for improving their sustainability (FOCUS ON: Interrelationships; Geographic Perspective)
Where does this activity fit within the Citizenship Framework?
What are the cultural, economic and human right concerns surrounding this activity?

Would certain food choices / buying habits change depending on the country which this activity was completed?
How is this lesson connected to current events and issues?
Students explore the economic, financial, environmental and social benefits of purchasing locally produced food.

They think critically / compare the costs of pre-packaged foods to the costs of food prepared at home. They make relevant connections to how their food is produced.

They also discuss the influences of various factors impacting food purchasing decisions such as cost, convenience/availability and quality of food.
Note whether this lesson provide an opportunity for field study?

Students compare store-bought foods to locally grown foods from a farmers market.

Teachers can vary the meals analyzed by the students to recent foods that are available in the community.

Differentiated instruction might include discussion such as where locally picked produce are available. Where hunting, fishing and traditional foods are acceptable / safe.

What are the opportunities for cross-curricular and integrated learning?

Science: Environmental Sustainability

Demonstrating a science lesson on sustainability, by using the pieces of the apple as a metaphor for environmental impact, ecological footprints, etc.

Humanities: Food and Nutrition

Students could use hands-on, practical activities such as family budgeting to prepare foods, and conduct research and analyze their choices.

Note whether this lesson provide an opportunity to integrate environmental education?
This activity provides a great opportunity to introduce an outdoor education component!  Students could expand on this by planting a school garden. This could be incorporated into assessment for learning through the environment.
Students could begin an inquiry project on topics like consumerism.  
They can explore concepts of budget, trade, logistics while beginning to explore the consumer packaged goods market.
By expanding to a very hands on version of this lesson students experience the benefits of moving from the traditional linear system of buying store bought foods, to a more environmentally conscious and cost effective circular economy of growthing their own produce.
Note whether this lesson provide an opportunity to address healthy relationships?
In an applied setting I think that this lesson demonstrates practical examples that would use familiar ideas to illustrate concepts in a very hands on way!

Using the placemat activity students will also explore, and make connections that support their awareness of healthy relationships through these probing questions:
“What do you do on a daily basis that makes a difference in your community?”

“How does the community benefit when you become an environmentally conscious consumer?

For example, bringing your own bag to the grocery store. Making the choice to be green: recycling, eco- friendly fuel choices, eating locally, growing your own crops, supporting green CPG companies: Procter & Gamble / Unilever. Using resources efficiently

“What actions could businesses such as grocery and other stores take to be more environmentally sustainable?”

Installing a green roof on the school, using alternative energy support sustainability.

Students could also assess trending dietary choices, and the effect on buying habits of communities. As primary research students could survey within their school to represent another scale, and build a consensus.
Note whether this lesson provide an opportunity to address equity and inclusive education?
Differentiated Instruction
Provide various articles and allow student choice based on interest. Articles can also be differentiated by reading level to support diverse student needs.
Note whether this lesson provide an opportunity to integrate financial literacy?
By asking the following questions I believe that this lesson really integrates an understanding of the importance of being a financially conscious citizen.

I find that this lesson is a great tool in beginning to analyse each students perspective on value. Through self reflection, and assessment of their everyday habits, use of resources, and their own personal take budgeting students develop a critical perspective. They are able to compare, and review their habits as a whole, and gain a critical perspective towards their personal choices.

Also, they are able to look into the issue with a financial lense and on  global scale by comparing and contrasting local vs international companies.

Note whether this lesson provide an opportunity to address 21st century skills (critical thinking, communication, collaboration, ICT)?
I think that using real life examples, and the scale demonstration of of activity really hits home. The minds on portion of this lesson is very shocking way of putting consumerism into perspective.
“At least it was for me as a student teacher the first time we were introduced to it.”

Students are challenged to inquiry about their own schema which allows for a great transition into the inquiry process! Then they research by reading the assigned articles, and communicate effectively using the Quiz model provided they can hone their critical thinking, communication, and collaboration skills.


Lesson Review


I think that this lesson is innovative because it's very adaptable! The apple as the earth can be represented in many ways. Also, for the purpose of tending to an applied grade 9 classroom I really enjoyed the final activity as it allows for a very practical application of their learning!  Having students work together to create their own real life scale, putting consumerism into perspective by:
  • Breaking down their own meal choices in class by physically buying the materials & creating the product.
  • How to create a budget & make healthy / responsible buying decisions
  • The outdoor education component! As an extension to this lesson students can grow their own fruits/ vegetables: analyze possible meal plan savings when comparing substituting the locally grown produce to the store bought produce!


I chose it also because it touches on sustainability. Teachers could adapt it to environmental impacts of our ecological footprints  farming, land use, and adding values to pieces of the apple. Focusing on the importance of land use, rather than consumer choices focusing more in conservation rather than interpersonal relationships!  Students can focus the inquiry portion, quiz, or discussions around these central topics:
    • Farming
    • Homes
    • Pastures or land for livestock.
    • Parks, sports, and recreation.
    • Wildlife habitat wetlands,mountain ranges, forests, deserts, beaches
The critical reflection questions would be based on using land wisely, soil choices, and location.
The outdoor portion will be possible however, a trial an error can be adapted by growing crops with locations in mind. Students would inquiry about soil choices, the location chosen, and their gardens would be planted using acquired knowledge surrounding these choices. They would then measure the effects on the surrounding environment of the proposed “geographical area.” Students could measure or compare the growth rate, effectiveness, and longevity of their plants/ fruits/vegetables. Although, there isn’t a heavy technological component for this adaptation I really feel that the scale simulations, real life examples, and the hands on demonstration bring life to this activity! It can be effective in diverse settings, and it double as being adaptable for various age groups.